Tamaqua, PA · Serving Clients Nationwide

What Happens to Your Pennie Plan When You Turn 65?

Quick answer

Your Pennie plan does not end on its own when you turn 65. Pennie says you must cancel your Pennie coverage before your first day of Medicare coverage. Once you qualify for Medicare Part A, you generally can no longer get premium tax credits on a Pennie plan, so any tax credits paid out after that may have to be repaid.

For many people in Tamaqua, Coaldale, Lansford and the rest of Schuylkill County, a Pennie plan carries them through their late 50s and early 60s, until Medicare starts. Moving from one to the other is mostly a matter of timing. If you get the dates right, your coverage carries straight on. If you get them wrong, you could pay for two kinds of coverage or owe money back at tax time.

Why doesn't my Pennie coverage stop automatically?

Pennie says plainly that it will not end your coverage for you, and that your health insurance company cannot end it for you either. You have to cancel it yourself. HealthCare.gov gives the same warning about marketplace plans: coverage does not end automatically when Medicare starts.

What happens to my financial help once I'm eligible for Medicare?

This is the part that most often catches people out. Premium tax credits are federal help that lowers your monthly marketplace premium. According to HealthCare.gov, once you are eligible for Medicare Part A, or once your Part A or Medicare Advantage coverage starts, you can no longer get savings on marketplace premiums or out-of-pocket costs. If you keep receiving advance tax credits after that point, Pennie notes that you must report them on your taxes and may have to pay back the overlap to the federal government.

A Pennie plan also doesn't lower your Medicare out-of-pocket costs. For most people, keeping both kinds of coverage means paying full price for a plan that adds little.

When should I sign up for Medicare?

For most people, the Initial Enrollment Period is a 7-month window. It starts 3 months before the month you turn 65, includes your birthday month, and ends 3 months after. Medicare.gov explains that Medicare coverage always starts on the first of a month:

  • If you sign up for Part B before your birthday month, coverage generally starts the month you turn 65.
  • If you sign up in your birthday month or later in the window, coverage generally starts the next month.
  • If your birthday falls on the first of the month, premium-free Part A starts the month before you turn 65.

HealthCare.gov warns that if you miss your Initial Enrollment Period, you may have to wait to sign up and may owe monthly late enrollment penalties that rise the longer you wait. Some people qualify for Medicare before 65 because of a disability, End-Stage Renal Disease or ALS, and different timing applies to them.

How do I end my Pennie plan without a gap?

Aim to have your Pennie coverage end the day before Medicare begins. Pennie lets you schedule the cancellation in the three months before your Medicare start date. To do it:

  • Confirm your Medicare start date first.
  • Log in to your Pennie account, open My Enrollments, and choose Disenroll from Health Plan for the right plan.
  • Or call Pennie Customer Service at 844-844-8040.
  • If your birthday falls in the middle of a month, Pennie advises cancelling before the first of the month you turn 65.

If you forget, Pennie says it may be able to cancel your coverage back to your Medicare start date if you contact it within 60 days of enrolling in Medicare. After that, it cannot cancel retroactively.

What about my spouse or other family members?

Family members who don't qualify for Medicare can usually keep their Pennie coverage. Pennie says you should update your application to show that you are no longer seeking coverage, so the household's financial help is recalculated. A younger spouse in Hometown or Hazleton, for example, may stay on Pennie for years after the older spouse moves to Medicare.

Where can I get help with the switch?

You can handle all of this on your own through pennie.com and Medicare.gov. If you'd like to talk it through with someone local, Stonebridge Planning Group in Tamaqua helps people compare and enroll in Pennie health insurance plans and offers educational Medicare guidance. Every household's situation is different, so check the details of yours with Pennie, Medicare or a qualified professional before you make changes.

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.

Stonebridge Planning Group is a privately owned, licensed insurance agency. We are not Pennie and are not affiliated with or endorsed by Pennie, the Pennsylvania Insurance Department, or any government agency. Pennie is Pennsylvania's official health insurance marketplace — you can apply on your own at pennie.com or by calling Pennie Customer Service at 1-844-844-8040.

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not individualized financial, tax, legal, or insurance advice. Rules and figures change, so please talk with a qualified professional about your own situation.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Can I keep my Pennie plan after I get Medicare?

HealthCare.gov says you can keep a marketplace plan alongside Medicare, but you would pay full price, your insurer might end the coverage, and it won't lower your Medicare costs. It is also against the law for someone who knows you have Medicare to sell you a marketplace plan.

Will I have to repay tax credits if I forget to cancel Pennie?

You might. Pennie says you must report advance premium tax credits on your taxes and may owe back any credits paid for months you were eligible for Medicare. Contacting Pennie within 60 days of enrolling in Medicare may let it cancel your plan back to your Medicare start date.

How early can I cancel my Pennie plan before Medicare starts?

Pennie lets you schedule your cancellation during the three months before your Medicare start date, so your Pennie coverage ends the day before Medicare begins.

Can my spouse stay on Pennie if I move to Medicare?

Usually, yes. Family members who don't qualify for Medicare can keep Pennie coverage, but you should update your application to show you are no longer seeking coverage through Pennie.

Ready to take the next step?

Your first consultation is completely free, with zero obligation. Let's find out exactly where you stand.